News Feed
Jobs Feed
Sections




News Archive
Mike Lively's Blog:
Why I Hate Singletons
December 29, 2008 @ 12:05:45

Mike Lively has posted a few choice words about one of the most popular and most used design patterns out there - the Singleton.

One of the most derided, yet most loved and used patterns is the singleton pattern. Its supporters continually praise its ability to limit instantiation of objects and its opponents continually chastise its tendency to be little more than a glorified global. While programming in many ways boils down to a matter of preference (you can always find someone that agrees with you,) I thought I might as well document my opinion so that those who don't care can have one more thing to ignore.

He starts by (correctly) defining a Singleton and why, because of that definition, they are evil - they become a "global point of access". Why is that such a bad thing, you ask? Mike By their design they mask dependencies, making it harder to do future development and/or maintenance.

I personally do not see very many viable uses for singletons and I know there are many people that agree with me (google evil singletons). It's simplicity seems appealing, but they are incredibly easy to use in a damaging way. This is the danger you risk with any concept that is easy to understand and easy to abuse.
0 comments voice your opinion now!
singleton evil dependency opinion global access point


blog comments powered by Disqus

Similar Posts

Vance Lucas' Blog: Protected vs Private Scope: Arrogance, Fear and Handcuffs

Jeff Moore's Blog: Dependency Injection in PHP

Zend Developer Zone: Design Patterns I Hate

Gonzalo Ayuso: Handling several DBALs in Symfony2 through the Dependency Injection with PHP

SitePoint PHP Blog: Evaluating PHP Applications


Community Events









Don't see your event here?
Let us know!


interview example zendframework2 opinion object release podcast phpunit code composer unittest testing database community introduction framework api language development tool

All content copyright, 2013 PHPDeveloper.org :: info@phpdeveloper.org - Powered by the Solar PHP Framework